Cognitive Stimulation Therapy - DementiaHub.SG

Cognitive Stimulation Therapy

dementia-hub-sg

Cognitive Stimulation Therapy, or in short, CST is an evidence-based, non-pharmacological intervention (NPT) for persons living with mild to moderate dementia.1,2 It was developed by Dr Aimee Spector, a clinical psychologist, in 1998, by reviewing the common non-pharmacological therapies for dementia, such as reality orientation and reminiscence therapy. The most effective elements of the different therapies were then combined to create the CST.

How Is CST Being Carried Out?

CST sessions can be carried out by anyone working with persons living with dementia, including healthcare professionals and caregivers. It is recommended for the facilitator, or the person carrying out the sessions, to follow the CST manual or be trained in CST prior to carrying out the sessions.3 The 2 main types of CST that have emerged from current best evidence are group and individual CST. Both types of CST differ in terms of setting, duration and frequency.

Group CST may comprise of 14 sessions over 7 weeks, carried out 1-2x/week in small groups of 4-6 in settings such as residential settings, hospitals and daycare centres.1,3,4 Following the completion of 14 sessions, the group may continue with maintenance CST at 1x/week over 24 weeks.1,4

Individual CST is suitable for persons living with dementia who are unable to participate in groups due to personal preference, social issues or mobility issues.1 It can be carried out at home with the person living with dementia.

General Principles of CST

Successful implementation of CST is dependent on various factors, such as the facilitator’s “therapeutic use of self”: one’s ability to adapt the activities to suit the individual/group’s interests, abilities and preferences,5 and guiding principles. Below are the key guiding principles for conducting CST sessions adapted from the “Journey with You” Programme Manual by Dementia Singapore and Cognitive Stimulation Therapy.

Themed Activities Adapted to Local Context

Each session follows a theme which determines the main activities that occur in the session. It is highly recommended for the activities to be as “localised” as possible to stimulate participation from the person living with dementia. Some examples are:

• Childhood games e.g. five stones, marbles
• Current affairs e.g. newspaper cuttings from Straits Times, Lianhe Wanbao, Berita Harian
• Food e.g. tasting Nonya kueh, hawker centre food
• Supermarket shopping e.g. budgeting for groceries using local currency

Conducive Environment & Pace

The session is carried out at a location that is familiar and comfortable to the person living with dementia. It is preferable to choose a location with minimal distractions and noise. For group CST, it may consist of persons living with dementia with similar background and interests to foster a sense of belonging and cohesion.

Providing Involvement & Inclusion

Just like how one feels valued from being listened to, the facilitator must acknowledge the perspective of the person living with dementia, and support his feelings through validation and reminiscence. Reminiscence can also be used to orientate to the here and now.

Giving Respect

Respect the person living with dementia as someone who has a lifetime worth of experiences, and support his identity and dignity. One can show this respect by communicating with them as an individual in their own right, and being curious about their life story, such as about what this person was like at different periods of their life.

Involve the Senses

Use different senses to help bring back memories: Involve things to see, hear, touch, taste and smell. For example, one can play music that may be familiar to the person, or let the person smell food or ingredients that may be familiar to them.

Opinions Rather Than Facts

Encourage sharing of opinions, rather than focusing on facts. Using opinion-focused questions e.g. “what do you think..” with no right or wrong answers. Every contribution should be perceived as a “success”.5

Support Creativity

Encourage new, meaningful connection of thoughts and ideas through conversations and discussions.

Stimulating Language

Ask questions such as “who”, “what”, “where”, “how” and “why” to stimulate conversations. Offer choices when possible.

Maximising Potential

Provide activities and explore new possibilities which utilise one’s strengths.

Providing Choice & Fun

Ensure a variety of activities aligned to the person’s interests/leisure preferences. Introducing new activities is a good way to stimulate interest and motivation.

There needs to be a balance between providing structure and routine and providing sessions that are not too predictable. Doing so will continue to gently challenge and stimulate the person living with dementia to stretch their cognitive abilities.5

Benefits of CST for Persons Living With Dementia

Research has looked into how participation in CST has influenced the cognition of persons living with dementia and quality of life (QoL) for both themselves and their caregivers.

Positive Impact on Cognition & Functional Abilities

Cognition, or simplified as “thinking skills”, refers to one’s ability to think, plan, and carry out activities.

A review of current studies showed that CST had a beneficial effect on cognition, self-reported QoL and wellbeing, as well as communication and social interaction.5 However, there was no significant effect on mood, activities of daily living (ADLs), general behaviour, caregiver depression, anxiety or burden.5

In spite of no significant improvements, there is evidence that ADL performance may be retained by continued participation in mentally stimulating activities.6 In some studies,2,7 participants who were engaged in CST reported improved memory retention and recall. There were also improvements in alertness and concentration levels, described as a sense of being more “switched on” and wanting to attend to things more, leading to more participation in ADLs. In addition, caregivers reported that they observed improved verbal abilities in their loved ones during everyday activities.7

Such positive gains in cognition can lead to an improved quality of life for both the PwD and their caregivers.1,2

Positive Impact on Everyday Life

Improved QoL
Due to cognitive gains such as feeling alert, increased awareness of their environment, and ability to process their thoughts better8 as a result of consistent engagement in CST, it is natural for both PwDs and their caregivers to report experiencing increased QoL.

Opportunity to talk and reminisce
Often, boredom and lack of interest to do activities are negative signs of well-being observed in persons living with dementia which are brought about by lack of opportunities for activity engagement.5

When engaged in CST, it is common for persons living with dementia to smile and laugh, which are signs of positive well-being.5 In addition, the opportunity to engage in stimulating conversations/discussions with like-minded peers also help persons living with dementia and caregivers to stay connected with their families, friends and communities,8 and forge new relationships.5 Persons living with dementia also stay motivated to interact with one another because the interaction was on their terms and at their pace.5,7 These further enhanced well being by promoting a sense of belonging to a community, which made the persons living with dementia look forward to future sessions and also increase their willingness to try out new activities.5

Sense of pleasure and enjoyment
Most persons living with dementia find the themed activities in CST pleasurable, entertaining and interesting. For some, the feelings of enjoyment and achievement were more notable then completion of specific activities and was sometimes sustained even after completing the sessions.5,8

Due to cognitive difficulties, persons living with dementia may experience a profound loss in self-confidence. CST may help to restore confidence by providing the just-right level of challenge in its activities which allows them to utilise one’s remaining strengths/abilities.7 This in turn, leads to an improved sense of competence and morale, which also enhances one’s cognitive performance.7

Gaps in CST Evidence

Lack of Conclusive Evidence About Impact on Cognition, & Behavioural & Psychological Symptoms of Dementia (BPSD)

Research has not shown any conclusive results on the effectiveness of CST in improving cognition or minimising BPSD,2,8 even though iCST intervention provided persons living with dementia with opportunities to engage in mentally stimulating activities which resulted in their abilities to  ‘think better’ and increase their alertness and awareness. Besides the differing duration, length and number of sessions of CST which made examining the outcomes challenging, participant dropout rates due to lack of interest also contributed to the inconclusive results.8

There was also feedback that CST activities were not stimulating enough for persons with mild dementia. Future research should investigate suitability of cognitive stimulation interventions and the importance of matching activities to personal preferences and level of stimulation.8

Caregiver-Identified Barriers

Some caregivers found conducting CST for persons living with dementia challenging because of the progressive nature of the disease. Poor physical health or decreased emotional well-being also diminished activity participation for persons living with dementia.8

Some caregivers have reported that they found it hard to fit CST into a busy schedule.1 Others did not feel skilled enough to deliver the CST sessions, which could impact on the adherence to the programme.8 These may be relieved by having extra support such as involving other people in delivering the CST sessions during times when the caregivers were unable to.8

Due to the beneficial effects found, occupational therapists Hoffmann and Liddle (2012) concluded that CST ‘is worth consideration as a therapeutic approach’.5

CST in Singapore

CST is not a common intervention approach used for persons living with dementia admitted to acute/community hospital settings as the focus is mainly on medical treatment and rehabilitation. In addition, there are barriers in ensuring that healthcare staff consistently apply the guiding principles when conducting CST sessions, such as the lack of mentorship and regular training sessions.

In the community sector, CST is emerging as an evidence-based and cost-effective approach for persons living with dementia in settings such as elderly daycare, residential facilities, and even as part of home-based services. More can be done in advocating for the benefits of CST on quality of life and well-being for persons living with dementia and training for staff to conduct CST competently.

References

  1. Yates, L. A., Orrell, M., Spector, A. & Orgeta, V. (2015). Service users’ involvement in the development of individual Cognitive Stimulation Therapy (iCST) for dementia: A qualitative study. BMC Geriatrics, 15(4), 1-10. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12877-015-0004-5
  2. Zucchella, C., Sinforiani, E., Tamburin, S., Federico, A., Mantovani, E., Bernini, S., Casale, R. & Bartolo, M. (2018). The multidisciplinary approach to Alzheimer’s disease and dementia: A narrative review of non-pharmacological treatment. Frontiers in Neurology, https://doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2018.01058
  3. Cognitive Stimulation Therapy. (2020). An introduction to cognitive stimulation therapy. http://www.cstdementia.com/
  4. Streater, A., Spector, A., Aguirre, E. & Orrell, M. (2016). Cognitive stimulation therapy (CST) for people with dementia in practice: An observational study. British Journal of Occupational Therapy, 79(12), 762-767. https://doi.org/10.1177/0308022616668358
  5. Murray, C. M., Gilbert-Hunt, S., Berndt, A. & Perrelle, L. d. L. (2016). Promoting participation and engagement for people with dementia through a cognitive stimulation therapy programme delivered by students: A descriptive qualitative study. British Journal of Occupational Therapy, 79(10), 620-628. https://doi.org/10.1177/0308022616653972
  6. Dementia Australia. (2016). Mental exercise and dementia. https://www.dementia.org.au/sites/default/files/helpsheets/Helpsheet-DementiaQandA06-MentalExercise_english.pdf
  7. Spector, A., Gardner, C. & Orrell, M. (2011). The impact of Cognitive Stimulation Therapy groups of people with dementia: Views from participants, their carers and group facilitators. Aging & Mental Health, 15(8), 945-949. doi: 1080/13607863.2011.586622.
  8. Leung, P., Yates, L., Orgeta, V., Hamidi, F., & Orrell, M. (2017). The experiences of people with dementia and their carers in individual cognitive stimulation therapy. International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 32(12), e34-e42. doi: 10.1002/gps.4648.
Skip to content